The ability to play by ear is a real gift – however so is being able to play from music. Maybe I’m being over-sensitive (I am a musician…) but the website reads as if this is some elite supergroup of musicians, and that anyone who plays from music is somehow inferior.
Would we say that a Shakespearean actor is any less the artist and performer if he cannot learn the lines the first time he hears them?
And in any case, someone must have played the music from a printed score in order for these ‘elite musicians’ to play the song by ear once they had heard it.
Apparently, anyone who uses printed music is ‘bound to a page of notes’ – this is nonsense! Printed music only hints at the interpretation – the musician still has freedom to play from the heart, once they know the piece and can feel it. Of course, not everyone does, but everyone could.
The website continues:
In coming months and years, other artists will be profiled Ã¢â‚¬â€ other artists who share Richard’s ability to create beautiful music solely by ear Ã¢â‚¬â€ music that flows from the heart. Real Piano Music is looking for other such artists. If you think you have the extraordinary gift it takes to be profiled on “Real Piano Music”, contact us. Send a message…
Remember, only very gifted piano players who can play by ear will be profiled. We will arrange to examine your music and your talent closely. If you have the right stuff, you will profiled on Real Piano Music.
When I was 4, I was told that I played the piano by ear – as soon as I heard a melody I would play it. Probably not perfectly, first time. I honed the skill, and I also learnt to read music. I still play ‘by ear’ but am certainly not ‘elite’ – I can’t claim to always be able to play any piece of music verbatim on first hearing.
I use a combination of playing by ear and using the visual musical language of notation. It works for me, and for countless other musicians. Some are more adept at one than the other.
Let’s not put a dampener on printed music – how on earth would some of our greatest classical music have survived were it not for preserved manuscripts?
I doubt I ‘have what it takes’ to join Richard’s elite club – and to be honest, I wouldn’t want to even if I did.